| 2012 | ||||
| First Base | Travis Caraway | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Second Base | Matt Johnson | SO. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Third Base | Tucker Alexander | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Short-Stop | Francisco Rosario | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Catcher | Brandon Cummings | SO. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Centerfield | JR Head | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Leftfield | Kale Thaxton | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Rightfield | Michael Cruz | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Pitcher | Dwight Camp | FR. | Carl Albert State College | |
| 2013 | ||||
| First Base | Randy Joung | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Second Base | Petr Sila | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Third Base | Casey Coyle | FR. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Short-Stop | Keach Ballard | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Catcher | Clemenle Parra | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Centerfield | Sherman Lacrus | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Leftfield | Alex Harris | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Rightfield | Noel Nevarez | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Pitcher | Ryan Lenaburg | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| 2014 | ||||
| First Base | Conner Counce | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Second Base | Randy Rodriquez | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Third Base | Brance Kahle | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Short-Stop | Tony Nunez | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Catcher | Cole Davis | FR. | Redlands Community College | |
| Outfield | Brandon Grimsley | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Outfield | Matt McDowell | FR. | Redlands Community College | |
| Outfield | Korbin Polston | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Pitcher | Austin Kretchmar | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| 2015 | ||||
| First Base | Nik Gifford | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Second Base | Tom McGarry | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Third Base | Marlor Villafana | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Short-Stop | Nick Yoning | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Catcher | Josh Anthony | FR. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Leftfield | Kade Carrigan | FR. | Redlands Community College | |
| Centerfield | Justin Ellison | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Rightfield | Lane Smith | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Pitcher | Ricardo Parra | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| 2016 | ||||
| First Base | Josh Evans | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Second Base | Bryan Hernandez | FR. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Third Base | Joshua Anthony | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Short-Stop | Alex rodriguez | FR. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Catcher | Harrison Hull | SO. | NOC-Enid | |
| Leftfield | Kade Carrigan | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Centerfield | Fernando Garcia | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Rightfield | Walker Whitworth | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Pitcher | Ariel Buros-Garcia | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| 2017 | ||||
| First Base | Braden Rogers | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| Second Base | TJ Black | SO. | NOC - Enid | |
| Third Base | Troy Black | FR. | Murray State | |
| Short-Stop | Bryan Hernandez | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Catcher | Miguel Lorenzo | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Leftfield | Will Klek | SO. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Centerfield | Taylor Avila | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Rightfield | Kris Prez | FR. | NOC - TONKAWA | |
| Pitcher | Avelito Encarnacion | FR. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| 2018 | ||||
| First Base | Tanner Long | SO. | NOC - TONKAWA | |
| Second Base | Gabriel Griffith | SO. | NOC - TONKAWA | |
| Shortstop | Tyler Smith | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Thrid Base | Ben Klutts | FR. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Catcher | Jacob Padilla | SO. | Murray State College | Defensive POTY |
| Leftfield | Sam Anthony | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Centerfield | Tyler Hawk | SO. | Redlands Community College | |
| Rightfield | Dominick Trevino | FR. | NOC - TONKAWA | |
| Pitcher | Billy Wall | FR. | Murray State College | |
| 2019 | ||||
| Catcher | Allan Berrios | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | Defensive POTY |
| First Base | Dan Pruitt | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Second Base | Cale Francis | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Third Base | Ben Klutts | SO. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Shortstop | Morgan Crenshaw | SO. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Centerfield | Caleb Upshaw | SO. | Western Oklahoma State | |
| Leftfield | Dom Trevino | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| Rightfield | Gehrig Octavio | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Pitcher | Tyler Kinser | SO. | NOC-Tonkawa | |
| 2021 | ||||
| Catcher | Braden Corley | SO. | Murray State College | |
| First Base | Dylan DeButy | FR. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Second Base | Jovanny Mijares | SO. | Murray State College | |
| Third Base | Ambren Voitik | FR. | NOC-Enid | |
| Outfield | Chase Keeton | FR. | Murray State College | |
| Outfield | C.J. Price | FR. | National Park College | |
| Outfield | Breck Burris | FR. | Carl Albert State College | |
| Pitcher | Braden Corley | SO. | Murray State College | |
| 2022 | ||||
| Catcher | Brady Evans | Murray State College | ||
| First Base | Jalen Hicks | National Park College | ||
| Second Base | Tyriq Kemp | Western Oklahoma State | ||
| Third Base | Ethan Moore | Murray State College | ||
| Shortstop | Adondys Hererra | Western Oklahoma State | ||
| Outfield | Chase Keeton | Murray State College | ||
| Outfield | C. Munoz | Western Oklahoma State | ||
| Outfield | Ryan Duncan | NOC-Tonkawa | ||
| Pitcher | Luke Livian | NOC-Tonkawa |